Here’s a game from a small studio on some unknown licensed property that no one’s talking about.
EA took some notes from the last Battlefront game and gave us a single-player campaign, which is what the Let’s Play covers.
Overall I enjoyed it. There were certainly surprises in gameplay and characters that were fun. However at around 5 hours, the story felt a bit rushed and undercooked. As a result, some character turns felt a bit more sudden and unearned. There were some fun Easter eggs but looking back, I think they only weakened the narrative and seemed like corporate mandates. Not enough time was spent on our new protagonist, Iden Versio.
That’s a shame because she seems interesting and shows lots of future potential. It helps that’s she’s given life by actress Janina Gavankar. It’s been fun seeing her do PR for the game because she’s clearly a big fan of Star Wars and has been a strong advocate for making games more legitimate in the eyes of the non-gaming public.
The multiplayer areas of this game is where the firestorm of controversy and outrage have centered. Honestly, I think the reaction is overblown but not wholly unwarranted.
EA has a checkered history and obviously views the games as a service model as a potent money maker. And we shouldn’t forget that this is entertainment for us, but a business to them. The cost of making a video game today is much higher than in the past. I have no quarrel with them trying to find ways to monetize. I think we’ve now seen a few examples of how to do it right and EA did them wrong.
There are other sources that go more in depth on the issue but my take is that pay to win is wrong. Microtransactions that give players advantages over others is the problem. Overwatch is a great model because there’s plenty to spend money on but nothing ruins the balance of the gameplay. Naughty Dog floods its multiplayer modes with skins, emotes and finishing moves, but no unfair advantages can be bought.
Even non-cosmetic DLC is okay for me in the form of additional story content. I bought every Mass Effect trilogy DLC and had no regrets. And although Mass Effect 3 had a multiplayer with loot boxes for better weapons, the game mode was never PvP so no one went up in arms. They also smartly made any MP DLC free
I’ve already written more than I care to so I’ll reiterate that the story campaign made me glad I bought this game, despite the issues with multiplayer. The campaign should’ve been longer to flesh out beats and maybe less fan-service elements would’ve strengthened the core plot.
Also, EA recently shuttered the studio that was working on an Uncharted-like Star Wars game. But there were certainly moments in this game that felt like a Nathan Drake adventure. Bombastic set pieces and high paced death defying antics left me breathless, and made me want more.